TheHarry BinswangerLetter

  • This topic has 7 voices and 6 replies.
Viewing 6 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #98492 test
      | DIR.

      There are so many terrific scenes in Atlas. I’d be curious to learn others’ favorites.

      Some of mine are:

      Francisco meeting Rearden.

      The bracelet scene.

      The scene where Rearden slapped Francisco.

      Galt and Dagny meeting in the valley.

      The Galt and Dagny meeting that led to his arrest.

      And if I was “forced” to name my favorite:

      The scene where Rearden met Ragnar.

      And does anybody know what Ayn Rand’s favorite scene was?

    • #106772 test
      | DIR.

      There is a scene that always comes to mind when I think of Atlas Shrugged. It is only a few lines, so I will quote it here.

      ā€œMother, do they think it’s exactly in reverse?ā€ she asked. ā€œWhat?ā€ asked Mrs. Taggart, bewildered. ā€œThe things you were talking about. The lights and the flowers. Do they expect those things to make them romantic, not the other way around?ā€

      Rand, Ayn (2005-04-21). Atlas Shrugged: (Centennial Edition) (p. 101). Penguin Group. Kindle Edition.Ā 

    • #106775 test
      | DIR.

      The scene where Francisco helps Rearden save the furnace was fantastic.

    • #106801 test
      | DIR.

      I have many favorite scenes in Atlas Shrugged, but this one above all:Ā 

      “Not a single mind left on Taggart Transcontinental.”

      The automaticĀ interlocker has broken and Dagney, dressed in an evening gown and cape is on the Taggart platform instructingĀ the lowestĀ track workers on switching the trains by hand. Ā In defiance of the preposterous situation, she throws herĀ cape open to display her naked arms and aĀ brilliant diamond pin against the glowing black satin of herĀ gown. Then she sees John Galt in the crowd of laborers.

    • #106842 test
      | DIR.

      It’s tough to pick just one.Ā  In addition to the ones mentioned above, Dagny and Hank on theĀ first train on the John Galt Line is one of my top favorites.Ā  When Francisco tells Hank “I have not said you needed it.Ā  But of all those whom you are saving from the storm tonight, I am the only one who will offer it”Ā is a beautiful moment in a favorite scene.

    • #107321 test
      | DIR.

      I really like the scene when Dagny meets Hugh Akston only to discover, later, that his name was plastered on the mailbox for anyone to discover if only he looked.

      The scene in which Ragnar an Rearden meet is exciting and compelling every time I read or listen to it.

      Just two examples of many.

    • #120482 test
      | DIR.

      Re: Ken Douglas’ post 100556 of 4/19/15

      My favorite scene in Atlas Shrugged is when Dagny takes Stadler to show him the remains of the motor. I quoted this scene in the personal reflection at the end of my graduate school thesis. The key line, for me, is “…He wanted a motor and he quietly performed a major revolution in the science of energy, just as a means to an end, and he didn’t even publish his findings, …he [wasted] his mind on practical appliances…”

      For one whose frightening childhood taught him to live in his own head and keep the world out, this encapsulates so very precisely a key theme for me in Atlas Shrugged: Of value to whom? For what?

      /sb

Viewing 6 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.